The fish'n'chip verdict on the iPad....

by handy giff-staffer gaffer 29-January-2010 16:34 - last edited on 29-January-2010 16:38

So we’ve had all hype and the pundit’s views on the iPad this week but the giffgaff team have just had a fish and chip lunch and announced their non pundit  verdicts…..and they’re not good.

 

So here are some of the downsides that were circulating round the table….

 

Poor memory capacity, no Flash player (what? You can’t claim the best browsing experience without that surely?), a SIM card format no one has heard of, not as good for reading books as a “proper” e-reader, locked to the Apple book store, locked to Apple’s chosen network partner,  no camera, no USB port and an inability to upgrade hardware and replace the battery.

 

There are of course the unsaid upsides of “being cool” and the neat UI eye candy. The price would be an upside too if the dollar price translated into pounds using a real world exchange rate – but the likelihood of that is about as high as Apple ever  conducting market research.

 

The concept is spot on – an easy to use, portable, big screen computer – but it only comes just the way that Apple want it to, serviced by a book store and network provider they choose.

 

It’s much the same with many other smartphones - Blackberries, Palms etc but what is smart about it? Hasn’t the web itself – the thing all these devices purport to access in the best possible way – taught the world that open standards and customer engagement are the best ways to breed the best services – would Wikipedia, Tripadvisor and the like be here now if the people that built the web tried to control what went on it?

 

Many of these companies would argue that bundling the applications with the device gives them extra revenue streams that ultimately allows them to sell the device at a cheaper price – they may well be right but that doesn’t erase the fact that what they are doing, in a small way, is limiting personal freedom. Why shouldn’t we all have the right to be able to use a device which we have paid for in the way we want to?

 

An alternative economic argument is that bundling services and devices in a restricted way reduces competition and that in turn helps to keep prices higher than they would otherwise be.  That’s clearly the argument that has won the day in some countries such as France where only selling locked devices is illegal.

 

So why don’t you tell us what you think and vote on whether device manufacturers should be allowed to restrict how we use their wares – just click here.

Comments
by richardhughes apprentice giffgaffer 01-February-2010 10:35

Completely agree with napachris, let people build what they want, just don't expect me to buy anything locked to a network. That's why I'm not going to buy an iPhone.

 

Although, never say never. I did hear the iPad will not be locked to any network... so how long before the same happens for the iPhone? Google have done it with the Nexus One. Maybe the stranglehold of the big carriers is starting to break. Let's hope so.

 

I am almost certainly going to buy an iPad, but not a 3G one. Wifi + my little Mifi router (bought unlocked on eBay) is the answer - far better than separate data contracts for each device.

by giffgaffer guide andy0 giffgaffer guide 01-February-2010 19:24

I think I'll stick with a netbook at a third or less of the price.

 

I can't see why Apple want $130 more for the 3g versions. The aerial, the modem, and the sockets for the modem and SIM card should be a few quid each.

by brigitte 08-February-2010 15:59

Surely they have to port flash to the iPad? After all you can use it on all other Mac computers and it's standard internet fare.

by freebiesjeebies 18-March-2010 19:07

Learn how to get yourself a free iPad, PS3, PSP GO, Wii & loads More!

 

Proved Legit by the BBC, CNN & NBC!

Watch the proof & get started Go to! :

 

www.freebiesjeebies.org


 

Post a Comment
Be sure to enter a unique name. You can't reuse a name that's already in use.
Be sure to enter a unique email address. You can't reuse an email address that's already in use.
Type the characters you see in the picture above.Type the numbers you hear.
Announcements

GET EXTRA SIMs: Order a free SIM for your mate here and bag yourself 500 payback points


Feeling handy? Help another giffgaffer out, see if you can answer one of these unanswered questions

Check out all the latest posts here

Join in on a giffgaff discussion here

Labels