Submit: Great giffgaff Ideas

Looking for something?
ryaneberry

Stop Kudos'ing On Duplicates/ Unsuitable

Status: Idea Vault
by ryaneberry on ‎22-12-2011 23:27

I haven't seen this posted anywhere yet but someone probably has. My idea is to stop the ability of posting Kudos when an idea has been marked Duplicate or Unsuitable. I have seen some ideas with the judos button made unclickable, so I am not completely sure what the case is at the moment...

 

Thanks

 

Ryan

Status: Idea Vault
Comments
by giffgaff Educator on ‎22-12-2011 23:29

We are currently trialing different ways of dealing with this. :smileyhappy: A meeting is set to discuss it in the New Year. 

 

I'd be happy to take any actionable suggestions you have into the meeting. 

by 1992chris on ‎22-12-2011 23:32
Seems good
by ibraheemjaved19 on ‎22-12-2011 23:32
That would work good
by ryaneberry on ‎22-12-2011 23:36

i think that if there is a duplicate idea then the kudos button should be blocked meaning that any further kudos can't be given 

by kabzzzygg on ‎22-12-2011 23:37
How can u make sure remarks when you have not seen these posts?? Weird :smileysad:
by as7861 ‎22-12-2011 23:42 - edited ‎23-12-2011 00:02

maybe auto locking duplicates, don't know about not suitable as their is ideas that are marked as not suitable for not have got enough support.

 

 

by stephenmiller on ‎22-12-2011 23:56

What would be the reasoning behind locking kudos, what would it achieve?

by as7861 ‎22-12-2011 23:59 - edited ‎23-12-2011 00:00

@stephenmiller 

 

for duplicate ideas - people will kudos the link orignal idea.

 

and the not suitable locking i dnt know really as i am not sure about this being locked :smileyfrustrated:

by stephenmiller on ‎23-12-2011 00:05

I don't think locking kudos will have that effect, more than likely it'll just infuriate people that are locked out from giving kudos.

 

The way to get people to give kudos to the original is to make the duplication status more prominent and for goodness sake have the link to the original idea in the standard hyperlink colours and format so people can see it's a link and not just a status.

by jamesd2010 on ‎23-12-2011 12:53

Freezing Kudos is an action I've seen happen several times this week. Is it effective? Yes. But is it off putting to users? Yes.

 

This would be more functionality to Lithium, but the way to deal with this is when the idea is marked as a duplicate - Nothing is locked, but the kudos button for the duplicated idea re-routes to the initial idea that isn't a duplicate. Seems a good idea I may post later, but... Only if it gets good feedback here?

 

 

Announcements

Join us for Call of Duty

Labels
Idea Statuses
Weekly Poll
How much would you pay to unlock a phone?
Top Kudoed Authors
User Kudos Count
231
195
194
163
144
Users Online
Currently online:4,016 members 1,836 guests
Please welcome our newest community members: