Thanks for joining the thread @magspider
, it's nice to see you back, and you're right in what you're saying.
I'll give you an example of just one contradiction/inconsistency. People making threads for their 'giffgaff birthday', i ask for them to be moved to the Achievements thread because, after all, that thread is supposedly for 'everything giffgaff related'.
But depending on who's on shift i'll get different replies, most Ed's will merge them because yes, that's where they're supposed to go, but here's where they then contradict each other, because at least one refuses to merge them and says it's 'fine' to make separate threads for their 'giffgaff birthday'.
So i've pointed out the irony of that, by emphasising the fact that it's their 'giffgaff birthday', so should be in the allocated thread.
No idea what the exact rule on this is, but considering all the other WFH Ed's merge them, i'd say majority should rule.